Critically examine the functioning of National Human Rights Commission of India (NHRC) as an apex institution entrusted with the protection of human rights in the country.
Deeksha Patkar, AIR 88, 2025
National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) is a statutory body formed under NHRC act.
Recently GANHRI (Global Human Rights agency) refused to recognise NHRC for 2nd consecutive time.
NHRC as an effective agency
a. Has quasi judicial power to investigate breach of human rights - Eq: Hathras case b. Takes suo moto action - Eq: Bengal medical student rape case c. Upholds human rights - Eq: Compensation to Punjab mass killing d. Co-operate & coordinate with other agencies - Eq: NCSC [?], NCST, NCBC, NCW. e. Submits report to president anually.
However there are some serious deficiencies in its
1. Related to powers - a) Section 11 -> dependent on central government for forces - b) Sec 18 -> has multiple exceptions Eq: Army - c) Sec 36 -> cannot act on complaints beyond 1 year 2. Appointment issues - a) Influence of executive -> PM in appointing committee - b) Delay in appointment Eq: No chairperson for 2021-2024 3. functioning issues - a) NO enforcement mechanism Eq: Dependent on police - b) Only advisory body - not binding - c) Delayed reports - d) Suo moto powers rarely used Eq: not used in Manipur. - e) Lack of diverse representation (stated by GANHRI)
Way forward (II ARC)
1. Constitutionalise NHRC 2. Autonomy -> funds charged on CFI 3. Own enforcement agency.
NHRC - as stated by ex chairman HL Dattu - is a tooth less tiger .