Topper Copies

Describe the structure and mandate of the International Court of Justice (ICJ). Also, enumerate the challenges it faces in fulfilling its mandate.

Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025

The ICJ is 1 of the 6 principal organs of the UN. It is the Principal judicial organ of UN

Structure of ICJ 1. Consists of 15 judges 2. Judges have 9 year terms 3. Judges are selected by UN General Assembly (UNGA) based on recommendations of UN security council (UNSC)

Mandate of ICJ 1. Handles disputes between nations within its jurisdiction 2. Provides legal opinion when consulted by nations or UN agencies

Challenges in the ICJ 1. No enforcement mechanism for its decisions => Reliant on UNSC to enforce judgments 2. States can refuse jurisdiction - Eg China refusing ICJ arbitration on South China sea dispute 3. Judgments are often ignored by members 4. Can't handle disputes between individuals, unlike international criminal court (ICC) 5. Interference by UNSC P-5 members in appointments & judgments 6. Lack of sufficient manpower & resources 7. Failed to hold nations accountable in various issues - Eg Russia-Ukraine & Israel-Palestine conflicts 8. Accused of Western & pro-USA bias

Way Forward 1. Enhance independence in functioning & appointments 2. Provide for an enforcement mechanism 3. Jurisdiction of ICJ should be clearly delineated by agreement among member states

ICJ plays a key role as a global court, however reforms are needed to enhance transparency, independence & inclusivity of functioning