Lateral entry into civil services is seen as a reformative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.
Sakshi Jain, AIR 37, 2025
civil services are the permanent executives mandated with implementation of policies and laws.
Lateral entry in civil services - Reformative step 1. Promote internal competition in status quo civil services 2. Provide a new talent stream with industry experience (eg Nandan Nilekani) 3. Ensure a professionalised bureaucracy -> efficiency 4. Aligned with today's need of specialist . (Industry 4.0) 5. Promote COOB with industry and academic perspective in laws & institutions . 6. Agility and contingency model of governance required in present day -> expert advise
However recent UPSC rescinding of notification of lateral recruitment indicate towards criticisms and controversies :- 1. capitalist model of governance against justice model of governance 2. No on ground experience of lateral entrants . 3. Theoretic bias against practicality of the ground situations 4. golden nexus will strengthen -> posted in connected ministries 5. Lobbying in corporate Interests not public interests 6. Dismantling morale of long service civil servant 7. Lack of cooperation and opinion in career bureaucrats and outsiders 8. Ignorance of long standing link and experience of civil servants 9. Lateral entrants lack attitude and emotional intelligence of civil services .
Way forward 1. Training - Career bureaucrats to align with present day challenges - Lateral entrants with on ground postings . 2. external expert advise in policy makings 3. Inclusion of technical experts in designing and implementing (Hota committee)
Hence , a middle path would be optimal.