Topper Copies

The basic structure doctrine acts as a constitutional compass in balancing Parliament's legislative authority and constitutional supremacy. Comment.

Hassan Khan, AIR 95, 2025

'Doctrine of Basic Structure', a judicial invention in keshavanand Bharti Case (1973), intends to ensure adherence and preservation of core constitutional principles that represents basic identity of Indian constitution .

Basic Structure doctrine : acts as constitutional compass balancing authority and supremacy

1. Legislative authority : Parliament can amend wide sections of Constitution under Article 368 . 2. Constitutional Supremacy : Parliament's constituent power can not alter the basic features - (eg) Judicial Review power can not be changed (Minnerva Mills Case 1980) 3. Democratic polity : is ensured with check and balances . - (eg) Indira Gandhi vs Raj Narain : free and fair election part of basic structure 4. federalism ensured : with autonomy of States in their domain - (eg) S.R. Bommai Case, 1994 5. Independence of Judiciary : to ensure Constitutional supremacy without fear or favour - (eg) Second and Third Judges Case 6. Preservation of Core principles like secularism, socialism, welfare state. - (eg) S.R. Bommai Case - Secularism as basic feature 7. Evolution of Constitution : as living document to address socio-economic needs. - (eg) 103rd Constitutional amendment : valid by Supreme court

'Basic structure' doctrine is golden mean to ensure constitutional Supremacy