Critically examine the 'in-house procedure' adopted by the Apex Court to inquire into allegations of misconduct against judges of constitutional courts in India.
Hassan Khan, AIR 95, 2025
In wake of concern of judicial misconduct, Supreme court established an 'in-house procedure' to ensure accountability while preserving maintenance
In-house procedure
Benefits of In-house procedure
1. Balances autonomy, Independence and accountability .(2nd Judges case - Judicial Independence - a basic structure) 2. Shield from excessive executive overreach - to create a threat in judges' minds 3. Avoid issues of vendetta with judges for non-favourably judgement by judges 4. Ensures that complaints are duly verified and enquired before any formal enquiry -> to protect reputation of judges 5. Ensures separation of power -> part of 'Basic structure' 6. Accountability is ensured if complaints substantiated and formal impeachment request to President
However, there are concerns with this in-house process -
1. Alleged violation of Principles of Natural justice 2. Creates doubt in public mind -> reduce public trust in judiciary 3. Violation of separation of power - by undertaking executive function of investigation 4. Undue delay and opacity in procedure - can create a shield for judicial misconduct 5. No formal statutory procedure to give its legetimacy or streamlining
Way Ahead
1. Constitutional or legislative framework for independent investigative body. 2. Revival of Judicial Accountability and ethics Bill 2010 3. Transparent procedure for In-house enquiry.