Topper Copies

Lateral entry into civil services is seen as a reformative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.

Hassan Khan, AIR 95, 2025

Lateral Entry into Civil service refers to entry of private sector expert int mid and higher level position of civil service .

Lateral Entry as Reformative step

1. Brings sector expertise for technical policy making - (eg) Cyber security experts 2. Changing governance landscape with A.I., IoT etc requires expertise against generalist profile of existing civil servants 3. Brings innovation and efficiency -> reducing red tapism 4. Brings competitiveness into service -> reducing bureaucratic inertia 5. Address mid-level civil servants shortage (eg) ~1800 IAS vacant 6. Suggestion of various Commissions like Hota Commission, 2nd ARC etc

Yet, Lateral entry faces challenge

1. Concern of biased recruitment and Conflict of Interest 2. Significant difference in public administration approach of service while private sector approach of profit 3. Concern of emergence of Spoils system -> affecting political neutrality 4. Considered as attack on affirmative action -> limiting marginalised section representation 5. Non-implementation of policies due to bureaucratic resistance at lower level 6. Divergence between ground reality (Conventional civil servants are aware) and hypothetical policy making .

Suggestions

1. Ensure Institutional involvement of UPSC in all recruitment 2. Affirmative action to be incorporated 3. Clear criteria, transparent process

In long term, need is to strengthen the speciality among conventional civil service based on 2nd ARC recommendati