Discuss the role of the Supreme Court of India in strengthening the hands of the Election Commission in the discharge of its constitutional responsibility of conducting free and fair elections in the country.
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Article 324 provides for an Election Commission of India for conducting "free and fair" elections in the country.
Role of Supreme Court in strengthening the hands of the Election Commission of India
1. Strengthening the independence of the Election Commission - eg) In the Anoop Baranwal case, the SC held that the CEC would be elected by a 3-member panel
2. Giving it varied powers to conduct free and fair elections - eg) SC in the Mohinder Singh Gill case held that the Election Commission of India has plenary powers for conducting elections 3. Ensuring absolute neutrality of the CEC - eg) SC in the TN Seshan case upheld the independence of the EC
However, there are certain shortcomings that still exist: 1. The ruling of Anoop Baranwal has been overturned by the introduction of a bill recently to remove the CJI from the panel 2. Even the presence of the CJI does not ensure absolute neutrality of the CEC 3. ECI does not have powers to enforce the Model Code of Conduct - eg) NaMo TV was launched before elections 4. It cannot prevent criminalisation of politics in India (currently 43% LS)
Way forward 1. State funding of elections (Indrajit Goswami Committee) 2. Strengthening ECI by giving it powers of enforcement of orders 3. Creating a cadre of election commissioners to ensure free and fair elections
Free and fair elections are the bedrock of Indian democracy and for it the position of ECI must be strengthened.