Topper Copies

Referring to the case laws through which the collegium system in India evolved, critically assess its functioning.

Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024

Collegium system refers to the methodology adopted by Indian judiciary in order to select judges to Supreme court & High court under Article 124 of Constitution.

Case laws related to collegium system are 1. 1st Judges case, 1982: - It provided that CJI's decisions in selecting and recommendation is final. 2. 2nd Judges case, 1993: - It began a collegium of CJI and 2 seniormost judges inorder to select the judges. 3. 3rd Judges case, 1998: Expanded the collegium to CJI and 4 seniormost judges. 4. NJAC Act, 2014: It tried to expand collegium outside the judiciary by including the executive but was struck down in 2015.

Significance of collegium system are 1. Maintain separation of powers under Article 50 of constitution. 2. Ensures meritrocacy in working of judiciary. 3. Stops authoritarian regimes from exploiting the judiciary for personal gains. eg Indira Gandhi appointed her favorite as CJI instead of seniormost judge. 4. Appointment of seniormost judges -> Ensures continuity in system 5. In line with basic structure doctrine as judicial independence is protected.

Challenges with working of collegium are 1. Checks and balance principle is violated. as judiciary Independent 2. Law Commission, 2009 said collegium is means for corruption and nepotism. 3. Undermining the people's representatives although a democratic polity. 4. No reservation in working of collegium system -> Violation of Right to Equality

Collegium system must be made more transparent with a codified procedure in order to protect legitimacy of the system.