Basic structure doctrine has prevented the Parliament, a creature of the constitution, from becoming the master of the constitution. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.
Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024
Basic structure doctrine was formulated by the judiciary post the Keshavananda Bharti Case. It states the government action (legislative, go. executive) cannot violate the basic structure of constitution.
Basic constitution has stopped Parliament from legislative action as: 1. Parliamentary law for ensuring transparency in judicial announcements was stuck down in NJAC Case, 2014. 2. Minerva Mills Case -> It established that legislature cannot make laws violating fundamental rights except for DPSP 39(b), 39(c) 3. Check on arbitariness by Speaker in deciding Defection cases under Kihoto Hollohan Case 4. Executive use of ordinances was criticized as re-promulgation of ordinance is against separation of powers. - DC wadhwa & RC cooper Case.
However, the basic structure doctrine has also meant certain issues with constitutional framework 1. Violation of separation of powers and Judicial overreach eg Imposition of ban on liquor sale in 500 m radius from National highway. 2. No constitutional basis or constituent assembly origin of doctrine. 3. Lack of any codification of what comes under basic structure.
Basic structure doctrine has ensured that the political structure is transparent & legislative doesn't misuse amending powers.