"Rape is a rape; it cannot be condoned on the basis of the marital relationship between the victim and the accused." In light of the statement, throw light on the ongoing debate regarding the criminalization of marital rape.
Kashish Kalra, AIR 96, 2025
NFHS-5 data reveals that 18% women are unable to say NO to sexual intercourse with husbands.
Reasons for Criminalising marital Rape 1. violates the bodily integity and autonomy of women under Article 21 (KS. Puttaswamy Case 2017). 2. creates arbitrary exception against married women - not an intelligible differentia thereby violating right To equality (Article 14). 3. based on outdated maxims. - social : woman seen as property of husband - Patriarchy - legal : legal identity linked to husband - Doctrine of Coverture 4. "consent in perpetuity" is flawed notion ; violates Article 19. going against justice for women. 5. it is against international principles - CEDAW - UDHR. - SDGS.
Argument Against Criminalising 1. Difficult to obtain the burden of proof -> possible violation of privacy and dignity of parties. 2. Marriage as a social institution - creats expectation of reasonable sexual exchange between partners. 3. effect the family structure - noted by 172nd law Commission. 4. Potential for misuse - rising instances of Section 498 A misuse ; and dowry laws. - Eg. Atul Subhash Case in 2024.
Justice Verma Committee in past has recommended criminalisation of marital rape. But any step must be taken based on careful stakeholder engagement. Coupled with procedural safeguards + adequate sensitisation , laws for safity of women can ensure gender justice.