Topper Copies

Differentiate between the clemency powers of the Presidents of India and the USA. Also, critically examine the vesting of clemency power in the executive.

Kashish Kalra, AIR 96, 2025

India is a Parliamentary form of government and USA is Presidential. The President in both nation have clemency powers - but they differ.

| President of India | President of USA | |---|---| | under Article 72 | Article II, Section 2 of US constitution. | | 1. grants clemency for convictions under both Union and state laws. | 1. only for federal laws. | | 2. Exercise of power on advice of council of Ministers. | 2. Exercise of power is Discretionary | | 3. Pardon can be subject to judicial review - Epuru Sudhakar 2006 Case on grounds of Malafide, etc. | 3. It is not subject to override power. | | 4. Pardon results in erasure of conviction. | 4. Does not result in complete erasure. | | 5. It is unconditional | 5. conditions can be imposed eg. Norms of behaviour | | 6. Pardon only after conviction is awarded. | 6. Pre-emptive pardons can be given. |

ARGUMENTS for clemency power. 1. correcting judicial errors - during the course of trials 2. Prevent gross injustice - as it is matter of life and death. 3. serves as check - prevent any case of biases (race, caste, etc.) 4. Ensure that NOT populism, but justice is the guiding factor. 5. seen as an element of soverignty - vesting the power with highest office i.e. the President.

ARGUMENTS AGAINST clemency 1. goes against principle of separation of power. 2. absence of legal benchmarks -> leading to arbitrariness. 3. Delays in deciding - leading Judiciary to intervene. - (eg) Nalini and Murugan released on supreme court's orders Rajiv gandhi assassination case. 4. Potential for Misuse. - (Eg) Hunter Biden Case.

Need for procedural reforms + defined legal benchmarks to ensure transparency, fairness and accountability in clemency power. This will ensure public trust and REFORMATORY JUSTICE-