Simultaneous elections are advocated as a step towards reforming the electoral process and streamlining governance; however, their broader implications for democracy and federalism remain contentious. Discuss.
Kashish Kalra, AIR 96, 2025
Recently after the Ramnath Kovind Panel' report, one Nation One Election Bill was tabled and referenced to Parliamentary Standing Committee.
step: reforming electoral process and governance. 1. Only 5 year cycle -> enable policy formulation in stability and continuity. 2. reduce expenditure : Niti Aayog Estimates: Rs 10/ voter -> Rs 5/ voter/ year. 3. Inclusive political climate : as less mobilisation on grounds of religion, caste ; or even populist measures (cash transfers, etc) may subside. 4. ONOE : will fill the governance deficit - as logistic preparation : security forces, administrators, teachers etc will only be deployed once in 5 years. 5. Enable policy coherence : centre's funds will come timely to states -
But there are concerns 1. weaken the federal link - according to RK. Committee => measure will require amendment but not states' ratification . 2. may lead to un-fair advantage to National parties - have more fund, resources. - further weaking federalism. 3. hamper the democratic spirit - citizens' displaying of split Ticket voting 4. arbitrary fixation of tenures => may lead to un-natural coalitions weakening the ideological solidarity. 5. concerns that it would encourage defections and horse-trading to save governments from falling. 6. the argument of saving money maybe short-sighted :- CPR estimates - 9200 crores spending to procure more EVMs , VVPATs.
often concerns in electoral system: [a bar chart on criminalisation: 42% for the 17th Lok sabha and 46% for the 18th Lok sabha] low representation of women only 13%.
while ONOE seems like step in right direction, any step requires careful deliberation with all stake holders. Coupled with electoral reforms - transparent funding, intra party democracy (Dinesh goswami committee).