How has asymmetric federalism helped India accommodate its diverse regional needs? Discuss with suitable examples.
Kashish Kalra, AIR 96, 2025
Asymmetric Federalism refers to arrangement of unequal powers in administrative, financial, legislative share between different units of government.
Horizontal Asymmetry between Centre and states to accomodate diverse needs. 1. Article 249: Rajya sabha by way of resolution can enable Parliament to legislate on state list Matter. 2. Article 356, 365: President can declare state emergency to protect constitutional adherance, and from threats.
Vertical Asymetry between different states ACCOMODATE DIVERSE REGIONAL NEEDS 1. Enable Equitable development. - Article 371: for Maharashtra, gujarat to constitute developmental boards - special category status to Himalayan states to support financially. 2. Protect security and from armed threats. - eg. Article 371 C for Manipur 3. Recognition of cultural diversity and ethnic plurality. - eg. 371 B for Assam. 4. Welfare and advancement of STs - 5th and 6th schedule : enabling Tribes Advisory Council and Autonomous Districts. (eg. Bodoland). 5. For National security: special status for NCT of Delhi Article 239 AA.
Despite these measures: frictions do occur: demands for autonomy, more financial devolution, ethnic strifes - Need is to work collaboratively : competitive cooperative federalism to uphold spirit of Ek Bharat Shrestha Bharat and work towards inclusive growth.