Topper Copies

The Constitution of India provides several rights that empower the individual, yet it balances these freedoms with reasonable restrictions in the larger public interest. Discuss how constitutional restrictions on fundamental rights strike a fine balance between individual interests and societal interests. Also, mention the principles that are considered in evaluating the reasonableness of restrictions with reference case laws.

Vibhor Bhardwaj, AIR 19, 2024

Fundamental rights are enshrined in part-III of Indian constitution from Article 12 to 35.

Fine balance of individual and societal interests in FRs 1. Protection of women and children along with equality in all aspects : Article -15(3). 2. Backward class protection along with recognition of merit :- Article 15(4), 15(5) 15(6) and in employment under Articles 16(4), (5), (6). 3. Individual freedom but no untouchability right : under Article (4/A) - 17. 4. Recognition of merit but no privileges in society Eg Article -18. 5. Freedom of speech and expression but with societal good such as - - (i) Public order , morality - (ii) NO defamation - (iii) NO incitement in society . 6. maintaing cultural rights of tribes along with Rights to movement, Settle and Reside: - Eg Article -19(1)(d) & (e). 7. Protecting right to avocation but with restriction of public morality in 19(1)(g) article. 8. Choice of employment but no forced labour. - Eg Article-23 . 9. Protection of minority rights . Eg V/A - 29,30 10. Freedom of religion but with restriction of no conversion forcefully.

PRINCIPLES in restrictions 1. Proportionality Test: under which reasonableness of a F.R. violation is analysed - Eg In K.Bharati Case 1973. Article -39(b) &(c) were allowed to violate & FRs under A- 14,19. 2. Double propertionality test. Eg Electoral Bond Case 2024. 3. Impact Test - Actual consequences of a restriction and their impact on Fundamental rights. - Eg Putting laws under Schedule-IX and I.R. Coelho case. 4. Rights Test as propounded in the above case. 5. Doctrine of Harmonization b/w Fundamental Rights and D.P.S.Ps. Eg Re. Kerala Education Bill .

Reasonable restrictions are necessary for society to enjoy the F.Rs collectively in democratic way.