Topper Copies

Why did Hinduism-which amalgamated and absorbed almost every diverse faith, tradition, belief and practice that arose from within or outside, within its fold- failed to assimilate Islamic cultural beliefs and practices? Give reasons.

Saichaithanya Jadhav, AIR 68, 2024

Hinduism & Islamism are religious philosophy represented & followed by 90% of population in India had overtime evolved & assimilated in Indian society inculcating identity & separatism between two.

Reason for Hinduism amalgating every faith tradition, belief, practice 1. Lack of forceful imposition by hindus on others - resulted in compassion 2. Impact of Bhakti mvt inspired various people (eg) - Guru Nanak Ji 3. Polytheism as religion strata - amalgated different gods 4. Wide rituals, hierarchy - brought Division of labour - Buddhism emerged from Vaishyas

Reasons for Hinduism not assimilating Islam 1. Polytheism v/s Monotheism - different in approach 2. Lack of Idol worship in Islam led to Poor attract -venere in hindus 3. Islam is foreign origin - failed to imbibe historians 4. Heavy patriarchal attitude in Islam with strict orthodoxy 5. Forceful imposition from kings like Aurangzeb on Sikh gurus 6. Difference in language mainly in south India - Dravidian v/s Indo Aryan of Urdu

Therefore despite difference there is need of tolerance among Society rather than assimilation to abide to fraternity principle provided in Indian Constitution