How will you explain that Indian federalism is a happy mix of Unitarianism and confederalism?
Shivansh Subhash Jagade, AIR 26, 2024
BR Ambedkar said "Indian polity is both Federal & Unitary, changing its shape according to circumstances."
It has both Unitary & Federal aspects to realise
Confederalism Features in Indian Polity 1. 7th schedule (Elaborate division of powers) 2. Inter-State Council (to foster co-operation) 3. Rigidity of Constitution (so that centre doesn't change Federal feature unilaterally, Article 368) has this safeguard 4. Independence of Judiciary (as Check on Legislature) 5. Supremacy of constitution 6. Right of Interstate commerce (361) 7. NITI Aayog + Interstate forum + NITI council for N-E 8. GST Council - Foster Inter-state co-op in taxation
However, Polity also has unitary features 1. Emergency powers (Unilateral power to centre) 2. Role of Governor (check of state govt A-356, A-263) 3. Flexibility of constitution (only centre can initiate Amendments) 4. Integrated & Judiciary 5. Legislative supremacy of Centre - President veto over state bill - concurrent list Centre prevail - Residuary power to centre 6. Unequal representation of State 7. Single citizenship 8. All-India services 9. Role of CAG & ECI.
Thus, Indian Federalism is happy mix of both Unitary & confederalism federalism to encourage healthy co-operation & welfare of people