Legislation like Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act 1989 remains mere legal documents without intense sensitization of public functionaries and the civil society. Discuss.
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
India has various vulnerable sections as SCs and STs that have suffered historical injustices. To prevent their further exploitation, government passed SC & ST (prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. - provides for strong penalty, strict action on atrocities against SCs, STs.
however, it has remained mere legal documents as recently seen when MHA called in Lok Sabha, 2022 that crimes against STs
[a line graph of crimes against STs by year: about 6k in 2011, 7k in 2019, 8k in 2020]
This has happened due to - 1. lack of intense sensitisation of 1. Public functionaries - such as of criminal judicial system, police, lawyers that shame victims, eg 'prejudice of criminality against tribals seen against eg Irula community. - misuse power asymmetry & indulge in custodial torture, even death (eg TN) - refuse to file FIRs, investigate, go against higher castes in region. 2. Civil society - avoid people's stand of sc/sts.
However, there are other challenges to the implementation of act - 1. Act failed due to lack of overall empowerment of SCs & STs eg only 1 conviction when 97% of manual scavengers are SC & face health hazards, deaths. state unable to give alternate employment. 2. Non assimilation of STs, giving forest rights to them for empowerment, livelihood eg in Odisha land holding with tribals decreased by 12% in a decade. 3. Non-sensitisation of people eg 27% Brahmins still practice untouchability eg Chhattarpur incident, MP.
For empowering SC, ST & act implementation need - - (a) Development of human capital eg Ambedkar scholarship, Stand up India - (b) Rights give under FRA, PESA, 1996 etc. - (c) Sensitisation of whole society via education - (d) organisational structure, proper transparency in Bureaucracy, public functionaries
This will make India inclusive & developed by 2047.