For creation of a stable, peaceful and prosperous multipolar order, UN Security Council (UNSC) reforms are an urgent imperative. Examine the statement and present a case for India's permanent membership in UNSC.
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
The Russia-Ukraine war has put forward the greatest challenge to UN and its principle of "collective security". we today witness a decline of multilateralism. Amid this, India has offered an alternative view of "reformed or new multilateralism".
UNSC - 5 permanent members (P5) - have a veto eg China, US, UK, Russia, France - 10 non-permanent members
UNSC had P5 since formation when only 51 members, to now 193 members.
So, UNSC reforms are imperative for - 1. Stable & peaceful world - Paralysis of UNSC due to "east-west" divide, and use of veto by P5 nations for narrow national interest - collective security - with attack on aggressive nation not operational eg Russia-Ukraine war 2. Multipolar world - UNSC not representative eg no nation from Africa, South America
So reform - veto reform / Membership reform } needed
Out of membership reform - Kofi Annan has presented formula A & formula B.
The imperative of UNSC reforms has made it necessary for India's membership as- 1. India's cosmopolitan culture, our values of "Vasudhaiva Kutumbhkan" - our interest not in conflict with international peace. 2. Article 51 - our promise for respecting international law & strive peace 3. India - largest contributor to UN peacekeeping eg women contingent to Liberia 4. Largest democracy - fulfil the democracy deficit of UNSC 5. Largest population - make UNSC representative 6. Fastest growing economy : IMF "bright star" & 5th largest economy 7. One of the biggest military eg SIPRI: 3rd largest military spender 8. Nuclear weapon nation 9. Voice of global south eg won 8 times non-permanent seat by huge margin
Reformed multilateralism is must to find solution to global common problems of climate change, terrorism, inter & intra state conflicts eg Sudan, Russia-Ukraine.