In a metropolitan city of India, the law enforcement authorities decided to adopt facial recognition technology to improve their crime-fighting capabilities. They implemented a facial recognition system that integrated with existing surveillance cameras across the city, allowing real-time identification and tracking of individuals. The system was intended to assist in identifying known criminals, missing persons, and suspects in ongoing investigations. One evening, a woman reported a mugging incident where the perpetrator wore a hoodie, obscuring most of his face. The victim provided a vague description to the police, and based on that information, the authorities decided to use facial recognition technology to locate potential suspects. The system scanned through hours of surveillance footage from various locations near the crime scene. The facial recognition algorithm generated a list of potential matches, and one individual's image stood out as a close match to the description provided by the victim. The police considered this individual a prime suspect and proceeded with his arrest. Subsequently, it was discovered that the arrested person was innocent. Further investigation revealed that the facial recognition system had misidentified the innocent individual due to the limitations of the technology and the partial description provided by the victim. The police released the arrested individual; still his reputation got tarnished for life. He, along with his family, was evicted from their current place of residence. The psychological impact of the incident has been tremendous owing to which his job is also on the line. With reference to this case study, answer the following: (a) What are the issues involved in this case? (b) What measures can be taken to minimize the negative implications of adopting such technologies?
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
Facial recognition tech using artificial intelligence points at the presence of science without morality as a Gandhian sin.
(a) Ethical issues in the case 1. Presence of crime against women ⇒ against constitutional morality & fundamental duty to respect dignity of women 2. Technology usage without social proofing ⇒ tarnishing reputation - against Article 21 3. Collective punishment as all family was evicted ⇒ against justice 4. Lack of veil of ignorance → innocent until proven guilty. 5. Many suspects arrested ⇒ lack of accuracy & efficacy 6. Psychological impact ⇒ long term disproportionate punishment. 7. Use of partial information based sketch ⇒ lackadaisical approach by police. 8. Lack of clear guidelines about facial recognition. 9. Merged with earlier system ⇒ surveillance state creation possible.
In this light, major priority should be:
[bar graph: priority increasing across three bars — I: prevent violation of fundamental right to privacy of anyone, II: uphold creative use of technology to curb violence, III: systemic reforms & clear guidelines]
(b) Measures to be taken to minimize negative impacts 1. Use technology only as a means not as an ends in itself → supplement by investigation. 2. Right to be heard for natural justice to the suspect. 3. Clear guidelines to prevent leakage of information to society → punish police officer who leaks. → uphold right to privacy (Art 21) 4. More research to improve the accuracy of the technology 5. Provide psychological counselling and compensatory justice → to wrongly accused. 6. Clear SOP for future cases → step by step guidelines. 7. Upholding Gandhian deontology by listing range of technology → use activity tracer algorithm along with facial recognition ⇒ pure means
This would help to ensure that the technology is used keeping man as ends in himself while upholding the duty to catch crimes faster as "justice delayed is justice denied".