Topper Copies

The doctrine of Parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy has exerted considerable influence in shaping the constitutional frameworks of India and the USA. Citing relevant case laws discuss the role of the judiciary in influencing the constitutions in these countries. Is the scope of judicial review wider in India?

Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023

Parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy are two pillars of separation of powers envisaged by Montesquieu.

Influencing constitutional frameworks

India 1. Balance between the two principles is maintained - eg) Article 121 prevents Parliament from discussing the judicial conduct of judges 2. Judicial review has been provided under Article 32 and 226

Case Laws 1. Supreme Court in Vishakha Case, Prakash Singh Case has given guidelines to the government 2. Parliament's power to amend the constitution has been upheld under Kesavananda Bharati Case 3. SC in Madhu Kolmaji vs UOI has also exercised judicial restraint

USA 1. Strict separation of power between the two organs has been maintained 2. Judicial supremacy has been accorded explicitly under the constitution

Scope of Judicial review

Wider in India 1. Indian judiciary has been given powers under Article 142 and 132 (special leave) as well 2. "Basic structure" doctrine has been devised by the SC which gives it major powers

Wider in USA 1. "Due process of law" rather than "rule of law" is followed 2. Complete separation provides more powers to judiciary there

However, Indian judiciary through the Maneka Gandhi case has also come close to its counterpart in USA.