Topper Copies

How has asymmetric federalism helped India accommodate its diverse regional needs? Discuss with suitable examples.

Alase Hrishikesh Rajendra, AIR 61, 2025

Assymetric federalism is a type of federal Structure that in which each federal unit is not treated as an equal.

Assymetric federalism has helped accomodate India's regional diversity

1. Art 371A-G helps address the lack of proper mitigation of the North-Eastern states 2. Schedule V and Schedule VI along with Art 244(1) & 244(2) helps balance tribal autonomy with economic development . 3. Special category status (SCS) helps address the developmental defficiencies of border states (eg): Himalayan tellaian 4. Union Territories provide for central control over smaller federal units 3. Different financial needs are addressed through Art 279 and Art 282 -> Demand Grants . 6. Rajya Sabha itself provides for assymetric representation to different states . 7. Zonal councils helps deal with region-specific issues .

Issues

1. Leads to deferred integration of different regions 2. Issue of favourtism & vote-bank politics - (eg) SCS for Bihar .

Assymetric federalism should be implemented objectively and uniformly .