Topper Copies

What steps are required for the constitutionalization of a Commission? Do you think granting constitutional status to the Central Information Commission (CIC) would strengthen the RTI regime in India? Give reasons.

Nabiya Parvez, AIR 29, 2025

Constitutionalisation of commission as, the power given in Article 368 of Indian constitution, it will strengthen the institution by providing constitutional status .

Steps

Eg/ Earlier it happens for NCBC, NCSTs etc.

Constitutional status would stengthen RTI regime

1. Security of tenure to chief information officer - Eg/ Presently, only 29 CIs present in country . 2. Removal process require parliamentary approval hence it will be very difficult, it reduce the politicization of office 3. Allowance charged upon consolidated fund of India not on centre's discretion 4. Power of questioning and raising question without any fear - Eg/ like CAG (Article 148) 5. Reduce Backlogs - Eg/ Infrastructure will be developed 6. Transparency and Accountability to Parliament will bring innovation

Constitutionalization is not a panacea

1. Guarantee of tenure will not guarantee effectiveness - Eg/ ineffectiveness of NCSTs in protection of STs rights 2. Burden on financial resources of government - Eg/ still 45% funding going to salaries (Economic survey) 3. May leads to constitutional conflict - Eg/ openness v/s secrecy (official secret Act 1923) 4. Problem in provisions like section-8 could not be solve by constitutionalization

What can be done

Hence, 2nd ARC in 1st Report titled RTI : a roadmap to good governance, highlighted the need of Independent RTI regime to foster democracy in country