"The judiciary has functioned as an institutional corrective, redefining and refining the contours of the Governor's office to prevent its misuse and uphold constitutional principles." Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.
Nabiya Parvez, AIR 29, 2025
Integrated and Independent Judiciary as given in Part V and Part VI of the constitution based on 3R's - Restore, Refine and Refine the powers of executive .
Judiciary as Institutional correctiveness body
1. Prevent the misuse of laws in the state executive - Eg/ D.C Wadhawa case for re-ordinance promulgation by Bihar governer 2. Restore the Justice : Judiciary helps in restoring the Justice - Eg/ Ko Meghachandra case in Arunchal Pradesh 3. Interpretation of Laws which become cause of conflict between different organs - Eg/ shamsher singh Judgement (Aid and Advise)
Judiciary as Redefining body
1. Sets the new trends and precedence - Eg/ TN governer bills case, redefining the role 2. Power of governer under A356 - Eg/ S.R. Bommai Judgement 3. Role of governor in Understanding Article 200 - Eg/ Nabam Rebia and Bamang felix case
Judiciary : refining role
1. Judicial innovation - use of Article 142 to do complete justice - Eg/ west Bengal Vice chaullor case 2. Upholed the public trust - Eg/ Rajasthan Legislative Assembly case
But all these leads to challenges
1. Judicial activism - intervention of executive domain - Eg/ Mawlram case 2. Seperation of power undermine - Eg/ Directions to constitutional office holders . 3. Rule of Law threatened - as it sets the wrong precedence 4. Threat of federalism - Eg/ Kerala also move to SC regarding bills 5. Erode the trust of people in state functionaries
What can be done
As in Bal Patil case, SC held that Governor is a channel b/w government and state, Judiciary must respect the dignity of office, and intervention should be minimum (Adarsh sodargin case)