Topper Copies

Assess the effectiveness of Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 in resolution of river-water disputes. Also describe the potential impact of delays in resolution of water disputes.

Jeenu Sri Jaswanth Chandra, AIR 23, 2025

Article 262 provides for Parliament to legislate for inter-state water disputes and hence Parliament Legislated Inter-State Water disputes act, 1956.

Achievements of Inter-state water disputes Act, 1956 1. Provided peaceful resolution to many water disputes (eg) Godavari dispute 2. Evolved formulae for equitable distribution of river waters based on multiple criteria - need, usage etc.

Shortcomings 1. Excessive delays in deciding awards. (eg) 7 years for Krishna dispute- 2. Non-compliance by states and lack of enforcement powers. 3. Judicial interference prolonging dispute (eg) Cauvery water dispute 4. Recurring nature of disputes. (eg) Krishna dispute to get a 2nd tribunal

Potential impact of delays 1. Leads to politicization of disputes 2. The parameters used to judge may change (eg) Telangana appealing for reconsideration of Godavari distribution 3. Leads to inter-state conflicts 4. Loss of trust in the process 5. Delays lead to unreliability of data (eg) Change of river flow volume

A comprehensive solution like declaring inter state rivers as national property as done in Cauvery water dispute can be good way ahead.