Human dignity, stemming from right to life, does not end with death penalty. In this context, throw light on various controversies surrounding capital punishment in the country.
Jeenu Sri Jaswanth Chandra, AIR 23, 2025
In Mancka Gandhi case, Supreme Court held that Right to life (Article 21) includes a meaningful survival with dignity However, there is an ongoing debate if human dignity is violated with death penalty.
Controversies surrounding capital punishment 1. Religious view that life is given by God and humans have no right to take it. 2. Violation of Article 21 which makes Right to life a fundamental right 3. Retributive justice - Justice J.S Verma criticized it as sanitised form of vengeance 4. Victimisation of the poor - Justice PN Bhagwati opined that poor are disproportionately punished. 5. Accuracy - Since 2000, SC delivered capital punishment in 60 cases and later admitted that it erred in 25% of them 6. Necessity - 108 countries have abolished death penalty (Amnesty international) 7. Deterrence effect is questionable as offences are continuing (eg) Kathua case, Unnao case
Way forward 1. Law Commission 262nd Report -> Abolition of death penalty for all offences except terrorism 2. Swift delivery of justice.
A comprehensive study has to be undertaken with respect to necessity & efficacy of death penalty.