Topper Copies

The tenets of independent judiciary, life-breath of constitutional democracy, stand perpetually undermined by the executive encroachment into the judicial domain. Discuss.

Farkhanda Qureshi, AIR 67, 2024

Judiciary constitutes a "bulwark" of Indian democracy. It is the "Custodian of the Constitution". Recent conflicts between Judiciary - Executive led to undermined independence of courts.

Independent judiciary : undermined by Executive encroachment 1. Passing of 99th Amendment Act - National Judicial Appointment commission to replace independent collegium system. 2. Tribunalisation of justice delivery. - eg Nearly 500+ tribunals. 3. Thoughts of regional benches of supreme court without stakeholder consensus. 4. Politicisation of judicial post via allyed quid pro-quo arrangements. - eg Former CJI appointed in Rajya sabha. 5. Legislative enactments to nullify the judicial predicaments. - eg 24th Constitution Amendment passed to replace Golknath verdict

To address these encroachments, following can be the steps 1. Dialogue, discussion on the separation of powers / functions within their organs. 2. Long-lasting solutions needs like reforms in Collegium system. 3. Judicial restraint & objectivity as highlighted in NCT of Delhi v/s UoI case to demarcate judicial lines. 4. Executive must carry norms and orders as conventions to step into organ of govt. 5. Follow Article 50 (separation of judiciary & executive) in letter and spirit.

The separation of functions must be on the lines of checks & Balances for harmonious relations between judiciary & executive along with legislature