Topper Copies

Lateral entry into civil services is seen as a reformative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.

Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025

Recently the Government of India has withdrawn an advertisement of 45 post at Joint Secretary level. That raised the issue of lateral entry.

Lateral entry into civil services - a reformative step 1. It brings fresh perspective into the administration. 2. Expertise knowledge can be utilized in policy making. - Ex: Nandan Nilekani in UIDAI project. 3. Also brings competency in administration. - Ex: Urjit Patel in RBI as it's Chairman. 4. Brings the corporate style decision making thus making it quick. - Ex: Raghuram Rajan 5. It counters the Redtapism in the bureaucracy.

Criticisms and controversies present 1. No objective criteria on the basis of which appointments are done. 2. Allegations of it acting as a back door entry for corporates favouring government. 3. Also allegations of lack of fieldwork experience among the lateral entrants. 4. The issue of lack of reservations in appointments brings casteist remarks. 5. The clout of Executive without any independent selection committee.

Measures required to be taken 1. Lateral entry can be done in those areas where specific expertise is required. - Ex: In financial sector, energy sector, etc. 2. Keeping a transparent process in appointing them. 3. Training for a brief period after they are appointed 4. The Law commission and supreme court has favoured it provided it do not amount to favouritism.

The lateral entry into civil services should be based on some objective criteria to bring it's effectiveness.