The Indian constitution is unique in the sense that it not only creates a limited government but also establishes a welfare state. Explain with suitable examples.
Farkhanda Qureshi, AIR 67, 2024
Indian Constitution is a result of debates & discussions by Constituent Assembly for 2 years 11 months 18 days.
Creates limited government 1. Separation of powers and functions to avoid despotic rule. - eg Judiciary's role under Article 32, 226. 2. Checks & Balances agreement in Constitution. 3. Constitutional Amendment (Article 368) cannot amend basic structure of the Constitution. 4. System of frequent elections every 5 years. 5. 3 lists for Union, state, concurrent list to devolve the power to different organ. 6. Decentralisation of powers -> to avoid excess whims & fancies of any one organ. - eg:- 73rd & 74th Amendment Act, 1993 (Schedule 11, 12). 7. Role of Rajya Sabha & legislative council to check any hasty decision. 8. CAG's function to limit the extra expenses of the state. - eg:- Its role in Appropriation Accounts, Public Accounts committee.
Establishes a welfare state 1. Tribal rights taken under Article 244. - eg:- 5th, 6th schedule of constitution led to PESA Act, 1997. 2. Reasonable restrictions under Article 16. - eg:- Reservation for EWS (economic criteria) 3. Minority protection through Article 25, 29, 30. 4. Fundamental rights are protected through writs (Article 32) - eg:- Habeas corpus. 5. Right to equality (Article 14) ensures equity approach. 6. Protects the welfare of women => inclusive society - eg:- Article 24 -> avoid human trafficking.
Thus, Constitution is a proper synthesis of a protector, preserver of the Indian citizen.