How will you explain that the Government of India Act 1935 was seminal in giving shape to the Indian constitution?
Farkhanda Qureshi, AIR 67, 2024
Government of India Act, 1935 is the basic document that acts as the skeleton for the Constitutional framework of Indian law & constitution.
Seminal role in giving shape to Indian Constitution 1. Separate lists - Union, state, concurrent - highlight the adoption of these provision from Act. 2. Residuary powers to the Central govt. as in Act with the Governor / Viceroy 3. Provincial autonomy seen in the state autonomy of the today's Indian political structure - eg Niti Aayog's role in cooperative federalism. 4. Public service commissions (PSCs) like State & Joint PSCs was taken from Federal PSCs of Act of 1935. 5. Adult franchise to every citizen of India (Article 326).
But, many features of the Act of 1935 were differed in the Present constitution :- 1. Centralisation / Unitary features like Union's role in amending the Constitution alone. (Article 368) 2. Supreme court -> pivotal role under unlike Privy council of British. 3. Authoritarian nature of Governor was replaced by President as head of state.
The Act was thus an inertial force to shape Constitution. But the political & socio-economic dynamism also made its way to shape the Constitutional morality.