Despite constitutional backing, urban planning and governance have given limited dividends on the ground. Enumerating the reasons for the same, suggest measures to ameliorate the situation.
Farkhanda Qureshi, AIR 67, 2024
Urban planning got constitutional backing through 74th Amendment Act of 1992. This is in line with National Urban commission, that highlights cities as the "drivers of growth".
Reason for limited dividend of urban planning 1. One size fits all approach followed in planning cities => siloed way of governance. 2. Fiscal constraints - eg:- thin tax domain to Urban Local Bodies (ULBs). 3. Lack of skilled manpower & personnel. 4. Expanding rural-urban area, led to administrative overlap => crimes increase 5. ULBs have not been devolved enough core functions. - eg Water supply & sanitation still with state govt. in Kerala. 6. Insensitive urban planning. - eg Encroaching wetlands in Pallikaranai to make landfills (Tamil Nadu).
Impact of such urban planning
Measures to ameliorate the situation 1. Establish Urban Planning cell / Division for good governance (2nd ARC). 2. Effective devolution of 3Fs (Funds, function, functionaries) [Manishankar Iyer committee] 3. Active planning considering "city as a region" to make policies. 4. Regular elections via single electoral rollout for 3 layers of government - reduce redundancy in voter turnout 5. Ensure participation of community in decision making. - eg strengthen ward committees
Thus, convergence, collaboration and coordination via pro-active policies is need of the hour to better the position of urban areas.