In light of recent developments, the Collegium system and the Supreme Court's decision to strike down the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act, 2014 have once again come under scrutiny. Do you think that a NJAC-like body can make judicial appointments more transparent, broad-based, and accountable? Justify your answer.
Yashvi Jain, AIR 97, 2025
NJAC Act, 2014 came to life after 4th judges case through 99th constitutional amendment but was struck down due to violation of constitutional basic structure of separation of powers
Issues with collegium system :- 1. opacity in selection process -> black box appointment. 2. Judges selection of judges -> "Imperium in imperio" i.e. empire within empire violates accountability. 3. Nepotism & favouritism in selection process -> Uncle Judge's syndrome 4. Reduces accountability & transparency
Striking down of NJAC -> Issues 1. Against natural justice -> judges striking down act for judges 2. Against separation of power maintained through checks and balances 3. Long length procedure of removal -> No judge of SC has been impeached so far. 4. Absence of judicial accountability in unruly behaviour - Eg ex CJI Ranjan Gogoi -> sexual harassment charges 5. Favouritism & support from opposition parties strengthen security. Eg failure to impeach judge due to congress opposition
NJAC like body can make appointment of judges more transparent 1. Increase answerability of judges to the executive. 2. Ensure transparent selection process ensure quality of selections 3. prevent nepotism & favouritism 4. Enhance judicial accountability 5. Uphold the mandate of judiciary as the protector of constitution & fundamental rights 6. can include timely performance audits to ensure efficiency. - Eg cash found at home of former CJ Yashwant Verma.
Pursue of certain issues -> 1. Against basic structure of Independence of judiciary 2. Politicization of judiciary may lead to criminalization politics. 3. Money power eroding democracy, & rule of law.
Judiciary forms bulwark of the constitution.