Traditional forms of state-led accountability, also characterised as vertical and horizontal channels of accountability, are increasingly found to be inadequate, and a myriad of multi-stakeholder and bottom-up citizen directed approaches have come to the fore, to supplement or supplant them. Discuss with illustrations.
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
Accountability mechanisms have traditionally been either upwards to the boss or horizontal as CAG, etc.
However they had their lacunae 1. Lack of people centricity ⇒ imposed accountability norms. 2. Ivory tower syndrome 3. Top-down approach of accountability stifles innovation. 4. Lack of capacity of horizontal measures → lack of enough auditors with CAG 5. Collective collusion leads to violation of accountability.
All this calls for newer methods of accountability as -
Bottom up accountability - Social audit in MNREGA ⇒ very successful in weeding "ghost" beneficiary - Gram sabha planning and involvement in EIA/SIA ⇒ trust and demand based accountability
Multistakeholder approach - Environment as stakeholder ⇒ uphold ecocentric accountability - Eg Polluter pays (in plastic pollution) - People as equal stakeholder ⇒ prevented leakage of disaster funds in Kosi basin
Need is to diversify the accountability hierarchy for more effective good governance and weeding out all notorious elements via full transparency.