The reality of India's relations with the colonial economy belied the propaganda of white man's burden. Elaborate.
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
The British colonial government justified their rule on propaganda of white man's burden who want to "civilise barbarian" Indians & claimed they are ruling India for the benefit of Indians.
They showcased examples of - - -> improvement in transport by introduction of railways - -> communication by telegraph, etc - -> Economic integration with rest of world - -> Investments in industries for wage goods & raw materials, Eg cotton
However, the reality of India's relations with colonial economy was showcased by 'drain of wealth' theory given by early moderates including Dadabhai N. in book 'Poverty and un-British rule of India'. It highlighted - 1. The increasing impoverishment of India is not due to our resources or history rather due to unilateral transfer of wealth from India to England. 2. This was due to British faulty policies 3. Led to erosion of capital - making it difficult to modernise & develop Indian economy on capitalistic, efficient lines. 4. This drain of wealth was seen in - - 4.1. Direct plunder (Eg on artisans of Bengal) using political, military power - 4.2. Misuse of priviledges Eg Dastak - 4.3. Payment to SoS from Indian revenue - 4.4. System of 'guaranteed returns' or "private returns on public cost" - an example of "finance capitalism" - 4.5. The amount or salary to British officers paid from Indian revenue but spent in Britain. - 4.6. Cost of Indian army & men who fought for British imperial goals outside India - 4.7. The policy that allowed British businessmen to establish business in India - 4.8. Home charges paid to crown 5. British's 'unilateral free trade' regime under 'Industrial capitalism' converted India as supplier of raw material & importer of finished goods (RP Dutt - Economic history of India) 6. Did not establish modern industries such as heavy industry but destroyed earlier ones Eg shipping, coal, etc. 7. By land revenue settlement, led to depeasantisation 8. Deindustrialisation, ruralisation
This plundered India's economy & led to its share in world economy reduce from 25% (1700) to 3% (1947) - against white man burden