Topper Copies

Executive agencies, working as the watchdog against impropriety, are vital to act against the corrupt; however, pandering to vested interests may have the effect of turning the idea of rule of law on its head. Comment, with special reference to controversies associated with the Enforcement Directorate (ED).

Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025

The office of Enforcement Directorate (ED) under prevention of money laundering act (PMLA) is directed to act against illegal money laundering and smuggling.

Office of ED vital - SC in the recent Vijay kal Chaudhary case has upheld ED's powers as a 'necessary' step to counter ML - National and International jurisdiction to control money transfer - Clamp down upon corruption - Watchdog for financial probity as it has powers to summon + seize assets. - Really digital economy & ED needs to be empowered to deal with changes.

Over-reach of ED Office of ED has been criticized for : 1. Political misuse - 90% of PMLA cases against opposition parties 2. Low conviction rate - less than 1% shows ED used as 'silencing' mechanism 3. Process being punishment - ED's interrogation has itself become a punishment for civilians 4. Inverse burden of Prog - on victim increases executive domination in governance 5. Extra ordinary powers - to seize property and make raids hinders personal liberty. 6. Lack of public oversight and transparency as it does not release ECIR report.

To manage the raging controversy, there is a need to -> - a) make ED's working transparent under RTI / e-website - b) Build fast track courts for PMLA / FCRA cases. - c) Selection of ED to include Leader of opposition (like CEC)

The autonomous power of ED needs to be balanced by principle of Liberty and proportionality