Human dignity, stemming from right to life, does not end with death penalty. In this context, throw light on various controversies surrounding capital punishment in the country.
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
Capital punishment has been prevelant in India's CrPC which has invited varied controversies.
Negative impact of Death penalty - Retributive justice - as against reformative justice & is not in line with Indian ethos - Hinders Article 21 - right to life and liberty - Lack of empirical evidence that it is a strong deterrance - Ex: Rape cases still on rise - Delay in justice (Mercy petition) by president can subvert liberal democratic ideals. - Against UN charter of human rights (UNHRC)
Imperatives - Death penalty is seen as a necessity in rarest of the rare cases as pointed out in Bachan Singh case. - Provide quick justice of the victim's family. - Social ills a burden on society and needs a stern approach - Crimes are attack against the society + state. (Need law/order)
Capital punishment, as recommended by law commission must be a last resort and should be phased out to balance country's integrity and security with personal liberty