In the context of India, despite the presence of constitutional provisions, legal precedents, and international commitments that establish a robust foundation for a right to health, why has there been a lack of explicit legal recognition of this right?
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Recently, the Rajasthan government has passed a bill on Right to Health.
Presence of constitutional provisions, legal provisions and international commitments
- Right to Health recognised as fundamental right under Article 21 - Legal commitments made in National Health Policy, 2017 for enhancing budgetary allocation - SDG-3, Good Health and well Being, has been committed to by India
Lack of explicit legal recognition
Reasons 1. Budgetary constraints and commitments - eg) Only 1.9% of GDP spent on Health 2. Lack of political will 3. Private lobby of hospitals that are not under government
Way Forward 1. Enhancing budgetary allocations (2.5% target under NHP, 2017) 2. Strengthening networks of primary health centres 3. Promoting AYUSH along with allopathy to reduce OoPE (currently 48%, NHA)
"Health is the biggest property" - Buddha, and hence it must be promoted by the government.