Despite constitutional backing to the institutions of local governance, the idea of decentralisation has remained hostage to several structural bottlenecks. Elucidate.
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
After the 73rd and 74th constitutional amendment act, the local governance was given a strong constitutional backing (A243). However, there still remains structural bottlenecks.
1. Deficient FUNDS 2nd ARC has highlighted the financial disempowered state of PRI due to - High dependence on state/ central aids - No local fund raising - Tied grants for schemes - Lack of financial autonomy to execute welfare programs
Solution - 1[?]th finance commission has given an equal sharing formula to PRI's - follow principle of subsidiarity in financial / revenue generation - Municipal Bonds
2. Inefficient functionaries - Lack of coordination between state officials + sarpanch - un-empowered women due to sarpanch pati syndrome - multiple agencies overlap work - Ex: SPV's in smart cities - Delay in elections - Ex: Delhi Mayor controversy
Solution - Training formula for all office holders - Independent social audits - Karnataka model (1% - reserve LGBTQ.) - Political awareness via SHG to women.
3. Centralised Functioning - Lack of devolution of power to lower rungs - Multiplicity of welfare schemes - Lack of digitalisation of data/ records in PRI's - Non participative local governance
Solution - Social impact bonds - People plan campaign for inclusive planning - Activity mapping (NITI) for devolution
Going ahead, IInd ARC has also suggested formation of National commission of Panchayati Raj to simplify the structural bottleneck and achieve the dream of gram swaraj.