The true cost of economic and leadership gaps is deferred growth and skewed transitions.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
Have you ever looked back at your life and thought of a pivotal moment where everything changed? Perhaps an opportunity that made all the difference - and maybe one that circumstance prevented you from availing. This idea of moments that can change the very trajectory of one's life is immortalized in Tracy Chapman's words: "We got a fast car fast enough so we can drive away. We've got to make a decision - leave tonight, or live and die this way". For Mahatama Gandhi, this was probably the moment he refused to disembark from that first class coach in South Africa - his fearless defiance of injustice was the beginning of a lifelong non-cooperation against unjust laws.
Just as this applies to people, this idea of some moments and a few crucial decisions shaping destinies also applies to economies, societies and nations. For instance the year 2035 represents such very moment for India - this is when our demographic dividend will peak and we will have the largest proportion of working population in the workforce. But with the Skills India Report, 2025 showing that only 52% of Indian graduates are employable, the question is, are we ready for 2035?
I. Two Indias?
This question of where we're placed as a country and what our prospects are is difficult to answer. It is often said that in India, "if something is true, the opposite of it is also likely to be true".
So, we see two distinct stories spanning out: one is the story of incredible growth post the 1990s, and the other pertains to enduring gaps in our strategy of growth and transitions.
Jagdish Bhagwati has long argued that "growth is the wave that makes all boats float" - he argues that the 1991 reforms plugged crucial gaps in our economic system. For instance, excessive state interference, in the form of enterprise size caps under the MRTP Act, were against the economies of scale. The reforms, heralded by the resolute leadership of Hon'ble former PM PV Narasimha Rao and at the time, Hon'ble finance minister Manmohan Singh brought about a fundamental transition to India's economy.
However, Amartya Sen and Jean Dreze have famously contested this vision in 'An Uncertain Glory - India and its contradictions'. They point out that crucial economic gaps have led to skewed transition from agriculture to service-led growth. Service boom in IT-BPO sectors have expanded India's middle class and taken 25 crore+ people out of poverty (NITI Aayog). But it has failed to generate enough jobs - owing to low employment elasticity of services sector and high skills needed, making it an abode of opportunities for the more urbanized, better educated, privileged individuals.
Economists like Kaushik Basu point out that this skewed transition owed itself to enduring infrastructural and logistics gaps that prevented the scaling up of manufacturing. Coupled with a lower savings rate, there simply wasn't enough investment in manufacturing to lead to scale and productivity enhancements, crucial for manufacturing-led growth. The net outcome has been the proliferation of a few, high paying jobs in services driving growth - juxtaposed with near-stagnation in industrial wages. Our economic impediments, owing partly to colonial exploitation and protectionist policies post independence prevented a smoother transition to labour-intensive industries like textiles and toys, which would employ more people or make our growth more broad-based.
This deepens our initial analysis about pivotal moments - the 1991 reforms were surely a pivotal moment that set us on the growth trajectory. However, our choices were constrained by the state of our economy, with crucial gaps in the economy preventing broad-based growth, and leading to a skewed transition. It is precisely because of these reasons that the present government is emphasising de-regulation, ease of doing business and aggressive infrastructural development under PM Gatishakti to provide the structural basis for taking growth to the last mile. This indicates that visionary, decisive and agile leadership is needed to both capitalize on pivotal moments and set the stage for future prospects.
II. The Curious Case of Sub Saharan Africa
The importance of good leadership is underscored most prominently by instances of its absence. World Bank in an influential pre-Covid report took stock of poverty reduction efforts across the world. While most regions that made moderate to high improvements, Sub Saharan Africa remains distinct in that poverty rates have actually risen in the last 30 years! This is completely at odds with most global poverty trends, and very difficult to understand given the substantial aid that has been pouring into Africa!
In "Why Nations Fail", the authors reveal the preponderant reasons behind this seeming anomaly - leadership and institutional failures.
Successive military coups, authoritarian regimes and short-lived governments led to the absence of any long, development oriented vision. Piecemeal efforts were overturned in periodic civil wars and violence. Hence, their leadership failed to predict the impending water crisis, leading to water wars. They also did not lay down the infrastructural foundations for an economic transition from subsistence to surplus.
We can contrast this with South Africa, where Nelson Mandela's visionary leadership healed a fractured society - paving the way for a "rainbow nation" anchored in principles of truth and reconciliation. The African Constitution is testament to a vision of inclusive growth with expansive socio-economic rights, like right to housing and a living wage, and with strong institutions delivering a more inclusive growth model.
Our discussion of post-LPG reforms India shows us the salience of good leadership in commencing transformations, and the limitations placed on those transitions by economic gaps, which are being filled by current leadership.
Our cross-regional comparisons within Africa informs us of the salience of leadership in delivering inclusive growth and transition from subsistence to surplus - and the catastrophic effects of its absence. We must now explore the underlying reasons for the disastrous effects of economic and leadership gaps, and then explore a model for inclusive growth and just transitions.
III. The Opportunity Cost of "Falling Backwards"
Rational choice theory very clearly tells us that each decision has certain costs and benefits. In fact the cost of a decision, for instance, to promote heavy industries, is seen in terms of the next best alternative foregone, like agricultural growth.
Leadership gaps affect this equilibrium in three significant ways. Firstly, a short-sighted leadership may ignore the long-term implications of its actions, such as present US tariffs on India, which risks alienating India, US's close ally. Secondly, leadership may not have the right incentives, leading to profiteering at cost of public welfare, such as the mindless consumption of the global commons. Lastly, a complacent leadership may "miss the boat" on crucial moments. All of this can derail the economy, preventing sustained growth or just transitions. Economic gaps on the other hand, reduce the set of viable alternatives, effectively constraining choice - people are forever left choosing unviable "second best" outcomes - like precarious jobs in the informal economy.
The big question that remains is - how does one break the cycle? And going back to an earlier observation, what can India do to capitalize on its pivotal moment in 2035.
IV. Engaged Leadership and a Resilient Economy
I have previously argued that harnessing pivotal opportunities requires strong, structural planning laying strong foundations. Here, we shall seek to harmonize Sen and Bhagwati's divergent viewpoints to come to some general recommendations. A larger demography will need greater jobs, which can be brought in via Bhagwati's emphasis on structural reforms, like better infrastructure, increased scientific research, making investments in frontier technology and expanding our manufacturing base. At the same time, Sen & Dreze would remind us that we need employable individuals that can utilize the opportunities thrown open by just economic transitions. This would entail developing capabilities - literacy, numeracy, quality education, health, the capacity to reason and become lifelong learners adapting to an ever changing global world environment.
More importantly, deriving such inclusive growth and just transitions we will need a strong, decisive, visionary leadership - constantly taking stock of emerging trends and navigating constraints with agility - like a sea captain at the rudder. Thus combined, our "F-1 drivers" in our "fast car" can take us to prosperity, inclusion and empowerment.