Topper Copies

Independent judiciary is a vital pillar of a vibrant democracy; however, executive encroachment jeopardizes the efficacy and credibility of the judiciary. Discuss.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

The independence of Judiciary forms part of Basic doctrine of constitution as it plays a key role in safeguarding liberty and promote Vibrant democracy.

Role of Judiciary in Vibrant Democracy

1. Enhances political accountability - Eg: Lily Thomas case for instant disqualification of convicted 2. Promotes transparency, fight criminalisation of politics (~43% as per ADR) - Eg: Mandatory disclosure of criminal records (PUCL case) 3. Checks arbitariness and right to access to public information - Eg: Electoral Bond Scheme as unconstitutional 4. Integrity of election commission of India - Eg: Anoop Barnwal Case 5. Rule of law - Eg: Manipur case for timebound disqualification of legislators (under 10th Schedule)

How is Independence of Judiciary guaranteed ?

- collegium based appointment process under third Judges case - Salary on consolidated Fund of India - Conduct of Judges not to be discussed in Parliament - Contempt of court (Article 129)

Role of Executive Encroachment

1. Rising Tribunalisation of justice. Goes against Separation of powers (Article 50) 2. Constitutional amendments like 99th CA to influence judiciary appointments 3. over riding judgements to dilute credibility using laws - Eg: ECI act introduces cabinet minister for collegium instead of CJI, against Anoop Barnwal Judgement 4. Politicisation of judges misconduct - Eg: cash seizure case of SC judge and media narratives

Independence of Judiciary goes hand in hand with judicial accountability to avoid any encroachment by executive. The 3 pillars must work in tandem to uphold constitutional morality.