Compare and contrast the positions of the Speaker in the Indian Parliament and the British Parliamentary system. Highlighting various issues related to the functioning of the Office of the Speaker in India, suggest remedial measures.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Speaker of Indian Parliament and British Parliament acts as a guardian for Parliamentary sessions and as final interpretor of rules, convention in the house
COMPARISON
| Indian speaker | British Speaker | |---|---| | 1. Draws power from written constitution | unwritten constitution, hence draws power from laws, Rules | | 2. Continues as member of political party he is chosen from | Resigns from political party | | 3. Elected by the house in 1st session post election | Elected by the house | | 4. Resigns from post once lok sabha tenure ends | once a Speaker, always a Speaker Hence, can be called upon to preside | | 5. Final interpretor of constitution in house meetings | Interprets rules, laws and convention | | 6. Formal impeachment process mention in the constitution | No formal impeachment | | 7. Judicial review of Speaker decisions are possible | | | 8. Decides if a bill is money bill, takes up no confidence motion | Takes up no confidence motion |
Issues wrt Functioning of Indian Speaker
1. Allegations wrt Political biases - Eg: Giving more time to Ruling party to Speak 2. Against Constitutional Punctuality - Eg: Delay in deciding disqualification cases in Manipur 3. Rising cases of MP's Suspension from Political opposition 4. Falling productivity of house due to higher disruptions <-> Ineffectiveness of presiding officer - Eg: Shoe hurling, Chair throwing cases 5. overarching powers to decide money Bill - Eg: Aadhar Bill controversy
To uphold the 3D's of democracy - Debate, Discussion and Deliberations in parliament, speaker plays a crucial role. Necessary reforms are need of the hour to increase effectiveness of house.