"The 7th Schedule is vital for demarcation of legislative powers, yet it disproportionately empowers the Union, diluting the federal spirit." Comment.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
7th schedule of Indian constitution entails division of powers among union and States and aims to achieve federalism enshrined under Basic doctrine (SR Bommai case)
VITAL FOR DEMARCATION OF LEGISLATIVE POWERS
1. clearly defines the subjects under union list which is vital for national integration and unity - Defence - Insolvency and Bankruptcy 2. Enhance devolution by granting powers to States under State list - Agriculture - Health 3. concurrent jurisdiction over some of subjects like education, Taxation etc
DISPROPORTIONATELY EMPOWERS UNION
1. Subjects NOT mentioned under 3 lists comes under central jurisdiction - Eg: Residuary subjects -> Cybersecurity (unlike USA where states have jurisdiction) 2. Preference to central law over State law in case of overlapping concurrent laws (unless State has received assent) 3. number of Subjects in Union list more than State list -> overcentralising character 4. Encroachment of centre in state lists - Eg: Health: COVID-19 regulations under Epidemics Act 5. Constitutional amendments (like 42nd CA) not undone so far
7th Schedule acts as base for cooperative and competitive federalism.