Topper Copies

Despite its vital role for the smooth functioning of the body politic, constitutional punctuality remains conspicuous by its absence. Discuss.

Puru Dubey, AIR 86, 2025

Constitutional Punctuality refers to the adherence by the state and its different organs towards the provisions of the constitution in a time-bound manner.

Role of constitutional Punctuality 1. It promotes constitutionalism in the working of different organs. - Ex-> President to call/summon houses every 6 months; 2. It promotes coordination between different branches of government. 3. It promotes timely decision making & prevents delays. 4. Prevent authoritative decision making: - Proclamation of Emergency to be ratified within 6 month;

However, constitutional punctuality is seen absent today in various domains ->

ABSENCE OF CONSTITUTIONAL PUNCTUALITY 1. Legislature: - No appointment of Deputy Speaker so far in Lok Sabha. - No time limit for President to decide on the bills reserved by Governor, - No time limit to decide on defection cases. 2. Executive: - Absence of CoM during key meetings of the Parliament; - No time limit on tabling the Action taken report on various recommendations of constitutional bodies; - Delays in exercise of Clemency powers (A. G. Perarivalan Case) 3. Judiciary: - Judicial pendencies -> 4-5 crore case; - No clear mandate on the time to be taken by Govt. on collegium decision; - Non-prioritisation of constitutional cases gives Govt. a 'fait accompli'.

Way forward - Need for a second review of the constitution to address these measures. - Acceptance of various recommendations by Law Commission & 2nd ARC - Ex- Law commission 170th Report -> 6 months for speaker to decide on Anti-defection cases;

Constitutional punctuality is a key facet of constitutionalism; steps for whose implementation need to be taken.