Topper Copies

What steps are required for the constitutionalization of a Commission? Do you think granting constitutional status to the Central Information Commission (CIC) would strengthen the RTI regime in India? Give reasons.

Geetika Arora, AIR 22, 2025

Constitutionalization of a commission -> means, enshrining a statutory / executive / Non constitutional body into the constitutional parts / articles etc. - (eg) National commission for Backward class, constitutionalised. (Article 338B)

Steps for Constitutionalization of commission

1. It requires passage of a constitutional amendment act in the parliament, under Article 368 of constitution. 2. Can be initiated by any house at central level. (Lok sabha / Rajya Sabha) 3. The Bill, will be send to Parliamentary committee. - (eg) JPC. 4. Provisions of Bills, discussed, debated. 5. Passed by both houses by special majority (2/3 Present voting + 50% - Total membership) 6. Lastly, approved by President, and Constitutionalized.

\* Also if the commission has federal interests, 50% of the state's approval needed. - (eg) in case of GST Council - Article 279-A (101st Constitutional amendment)

Central information commission - is a non constitutional body, deriving power from RTI Act 2005.

Merits of giving CIC Constitutional status

1. strengthened the power of chief information commissioner to exercise RTI provision. 2. Timely filling of ICs & CICs vacancy. 3. Fixed procedure, maybe committee based, for appointment of CIC. (No central government bias as shown in RTI (Amendment) 2019) 4. It's Recommendation becomes binding on government. 5. Formalise the procedure to RTI requests, currently fragmented. - (eg) Hierarchy under RTI procedure

6. Significant, for reducing cases of corruption, scams (eg) 2G, Coalgate; through deterrence effect 7. Proactive disclosure of information, where secrecy is no longer the norm.

| Demerits of CIC - constitutional status | Way forward | | --- | --- | | 1. Increased burden on the exchequer. (salary, allowance - charged)<br>2. chance of increased complaints & frivolous burden on Judiciary.<br>3. lack of mechanism, or success examples seen. | 1. A parliamentary committee, including experts, officials, MPs to explore CIC constitutionalization.<br>2. opinion of public, CSOs, NGO etc. (eg) on mygov.in.<br>3. For time being, amendment in RTI Act for CIC independence. |

'Information is the coin of democracy', thus ways must be explored to give more autonomy & authority to CIC in India