In light of recent developments, the Collegium system and the Supreme Court's decision to strike down the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act, 2014 have once again come under scrutiny. Do you think that a NJAC-like body can make judicial appointments more transparent, broad-based, and accountable? Justify your answer.
Chitwan Jain, AIR 17, 2025
Recent case of Justice Verma being accused of corruption being in concern ours need for democratic reforms in collegium
NJAC Issue
- parliament formed committee consisting (CJI + minister + jurist) for appointment - SC struck down 99th amendment citing A.51 - Sepration of powers.
Need for NJAC like body
1. India is only democracy in world where judges appoint themselves 2. Democracy needs to be ensured via accountibility mechanism 3. Rising vacancy and pendency of cases. - eg SC - 86,000+ cases pending - HC - 6,00,000+ cases pending 4. Chance for Uncle-Judge Syndrome causing nepotism. 5. Low representation to women - eg only 1 women judge in SC (August 2025) 6. Ensure checks and Balances
challenges due to NJAC like body
1. Hampers principle of Separation of powers under A.51, 121, 211 2. Chances for political interference as seen during 1975 emergency 3. Nepotism may still prevail. 4. Dilute quality of justice and merit above quotas 5. Cause discontent among Judges due to seniority.
Best practices
1. UK has separate public service commission for judge appointment 2. S. Africa has elections among Judicial stakeholders
way forward
1. Establish Judge feedback mechanism to measure performance 2. Increase transparency by including outsiders eg Eminent Jurist 3. Public issue of memorandums
Thus Judiciary and legislature must coordinate not confront to uphold Rule of Law