Topper Copies

The basic structure doctrine acts as a constitutional compass in balancing Parliament's legislative authority and constitutional supremacy. Comment.

Geetika Arora, AIR 22, 2025

Basic Structure doctrine - is a Judicial innovation, emerged in Kesavananda Bharati case 1973, which provided 'provisions of constitution' which cannot be amended by Parliament. - (eg) Federalism as Basic structure, pronounced in S.R Bommai case.

Basic Structure doctrine - as constitutional compass and Balancing word

1. Prohibits the re-writing of the constitution by the Parliament. (adventurism) - (eg) Struck down of majority 42nd constitutional amendment. 2. Protects the most fundamental features of the constitution from Parliament's power. - (eg) 'Secularism' as basic feature mentioned in Preamble. 3. Prevents, arbitrary power of executive and demoting tyranny of majority. 4. Protects Judicial power within the Indian constitution as well. - (eg) Taking away Judicial review power of Supreme court, struck down. 5. Provides scope for amendment of constitution, to keep it relevant as a living document - (eg) 106 Amendments in around 75 years of Independence. 6. Basic structure doctrine; promotes the fundamental rights of the citizen. - (eg) Right to privacy. (Puttaswamy - A21) 7. Struck down 97th constitutional amendment (partially, as 'cooperatives' a state subject. - upheld federalism.

However, there are certain issues associated with Basic structure doctrine

1. Judiciary has not outlined in a specific judgement, what constitute basic structure, thus creating confusion amongst legislature & executive. 2. Judiciary doesn't have electoral mandate to formulate, struck down constitutional laws, amendment etc. - (eg) 4th judge case striking 99th constitutional amendment on NJAC. 3. sometimes, Judicial Review transforms into Judicial adventurism and over-reach. - (eg) framing policies, Allahabad HC necessitating government employee children to study in government school etc. 4. can promote Judicial supremacy against the constitutional supremacy. - (eg) 1970s tussle between executive & Judiciary.

Way forward 1. specify holistically, what constitute Judicial Review. 2. Approve, Judicial transformation (AIJS, NJAC etc) 3. Avoid Judicial overreach.

Thus, Judicial Restraint must be maintained to timely realise the goal of 'balance' between legislative authority & constitutional supremacy.