Topper Copies

Considering the non-enforceable nature of fundamental duties and directive principles of state policy, critically examine their impact in socio-political norms.

Puru Dubey, AIR 86, 2025

Despite their non-enforceable nature, Part IV and IVA of the constitution play an important role in our socio-political milieu.

NON-ENFORCEABLE NATURE - Article 37: Directive Principles are non-justiciable. - Article 51A: 'It shall be the duty' -

However, they play an important role in our social & political norms;

Role of Directive Principles in socio-political norms 1. Principle of Welfare State -> social expenditure, schemes for vulnerables - upheld in Art 38(1) & 38(2) 2. Key role of PRI's since independence - in spirit of Article 40; 3. Focus on maternity relief (Maternity Relief Act) and suitable conditions for labourers - Ex- Code on wages, Code on Social security in the spirit of Article 42 & 43 4. Excitement in politics about Uniform Civil Code (Article 44) 5. Educational & Economic interests of SC, ST; & weaker sections given importance; - Ex -> 93rd Amendment - -> 82nd Amendment (Art 335 amended)

Role of Fundamental Duties in socio-political norms 1. Standing up at National Anthem in cinema halls -> informed by Article 51A(a) 2. Protection of environment (Ex- Rani Samiti [?]) - informed by 51A(g) 3. Legislative measures for protecting the dignity of women; 4. Measures to promote brotherhood among people -> National Integration Council (1962)

However, they have also proven insufficient to guide socio-political norms due to their non-enforceable nature.

| DPSP's | Duties | |---|---| | reduction in inequalities not borne out (Gini Index 0.55) | promotion of common brotherhood only in letter | | effective role of Panchayats not borne out | defacement of public property in the name of protests. | | No uniform civil code as of now; | regionalism against value for composite culture. |

A strong public opinion & a political class with resolute will is needed to turn the promises in Part IV and Part IVA into reality.