Despite constitutional backing to the institutions of local governance, the idea of decentralisation has remained hostage to several structural bottlenecks. Elucidate.
Puru Dubey, AIR 86, 2025
Art 40 had directed the creation of local government bodies and endowing them with powers to act as self-governing bodies. Local Governments were given constitutional status in this spirit.
CONSTITUTIONAL BACKING 1. 73rd & 74th Amendment Act provided Part IX and Part IXA for Panchayats & Municipalities. 2. Schedule 11 -> list 29 subjects that can be given to Panchayat. 3. Schedule 12 -> lists 18 subjects that can be devolved to municipalities.
STRUCTURAL BOTTLENECKS TO LOCAL GOVERNANCE 1. FUNCTIONS: - (i) Insufficient devolution of power under 243A and 243W. - (ii) State Govt. directions to panchayats are binding. - (iii) Supersession powers are often misused. - (iv) Inadequate infrastructure available to local bodies. 2. FUNDS - 95% of budgets of PRI are dependent on states. - 93% of funds are tied. - Non-periodicity of SFC -> Only 4 states had created 6th SFC by 2020. 3. Functionary - Politicians (MLA, MP) dominate panchayats - Integrated services for panchayat keeps them at the mercy of states.