Topper Copies

Assess the effectiveness of Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 in resolution of river-water disputes. Also describe the potential impact of delays in resolution of water disputes.

Puru Dubey, AIR 86, 2025

Entry No 17 of List 2 places water under State's legislative competence. This has led to various water disputes, which require resolution for healthy cooperative federalism.

INTER-STATE RIVER WATER DISPUTE Act 1957 - Centre to create river tribunal when requested by states within an year if negotiation fail. - Judgement within 2 year + 1 year extension possible.

EFFECTIVENESS OF ISWDT Act 1956 Positives - resolution of 5/8 disputes so far Negative - long-standing pendency. Ex Cauvery dispute. - Appeals in Supreme courts. - Centre takes hands-off approach - Technical details used to contest judgement.

In this context, Parliament has tabled ISWDT Amendment Bill - which aims to resolve the river dispute through mediation & permanent tribunal.

However, additional reforms are required.

WAY FORWARD - Centre should use power under Entry 56, List 1 to regulate inter-state valleys - SC should exercise restraint under Article 262

By resolving such issues, we can uphold the federal model of our constitution.