Topper Copies

How far have Forest Rights Act, 2006 (FRA) and Panchayat (Extension of the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA) been successful in attaining their desired objectives? What needs to be done to improve their implementation on ground?

Sandeep Badad, AIR 82, 2025

FRA (2006) and PESA (1996) were enacted towards socio-economic justice and empowerment & development of tribal population and also other forest dwellers (FRA).

Objectives of FRA :- Undo historical injustice - Title rights to land, forest produce (MFP) - Rights of Community to common resources - Rehabilitation & Resettlement rights.

Assessment : (Land title) 1. Only 42% claims settled as per Ministry of Tribal Affairs in 2021. 2. More than half of total displaced are Scheduled & other tribes despite provisions. 3. Issues -> Demand for government documentation for proof despite no need as per FRA. 4. Rejection done by Patwari's, forest guards rather than gram sabha. 5. Xaxa Report :- No reason is communicated for rejection. 6. Poor awareness among tribals about their rights 7. Inadequate legal support/aid.

PESA 1996 Objectives :- Autonomy & development - Empower Gram sabha to recommend on land acquisition, rehabilitation & resettlement - Prohibit moneylending activities by outsiders - Carryout primary education, ferries, village market & other activities

Assessment :- 1. Gram sabha is defunct or acting as mere puppy to wishes of elite members. Infrequent meetings. eg Polavaram project 2. Many displaced people are yet to get resettled & those resettled are given useless land. Exploitation by moneylenders continue. 3. Conflicting provision with other acts like Wildlife Protection Act.

Success & Achievements 1. Samatha judgement led to justice for tribals regarding resettlement 2. Gram sabha in Niyamgiri passed resolution to oust a MNC which Supreme court upheld 3. Improved awareness of rights & safeguards 4. Improved political mobilisation & participation

But, largely these legislations have remained ineffective in uplifting, empowering and streaming the STs in democratic journey.

Measures to improve their implementation: 1. Empathetic forest officers rather than bureaucrats. 2. Stringent penal provisions with prompt action in cases of violations 3. Mission mode awareness & participation camps. 4. Simultaneous measures to improve socio-economic status. 5. Technology applications like Geospatial maps to Settle land titles.

Any action should be guided by Panchsheel principles so as to realise our collective vision of inclusive and equitable growth.