Highlight the key differences in the scope of Freedom of speech and expression as provided under Parliamentary privileges vis a vis Fundamental rights. Why is it necessary to maintain a balance between parliamentary privilege and fundamental rights?
Nausheen, AIR 9, 2023
Parliamentary privileges come under Article 105 while Freedom of Speech and Expression under the constitution is provided in Article 19(1)(a).
Differences in the scope of freedom of speech & expression
As Parliamentary privileges 1. Protection from court's action under Article 122 2. Rights to punish for contempt (Article 105) 3. No limitations under Article 19(2) except for speaker's action
As Fundamental right 1. Restrictions under Article 19(1)(b) - eg) Public order, sovereignty 2. Power of courts to restrict under reasonable restrictions
Necessary to balance between parliamentary privileges and fundamental rights. - To ensure equality among all (Article 21, Preamble) - Restricting Parliamentarians' use of hate comments - Unnecessary use of contempt of Parliament must be restricted
Supreme Court in MSM Rao case held that there should be balance between the two.